New York Times
“Gorgeous . . . . From a tradition of unnervingly confidential, light-voiced male singers: João Gilberto, Arthur Russell, Lou Barlow of Sebadoh, Elliott Smith, Jamie Stewart of Xiu Xiu.” – Ben Ratliff, on “Oh, Light”

NPR
“Intimate, quirky songs with layered vocals that flow over warm acoustic guitar. Lindley colors his soft harmonies and restrained writing style with carefully placed electronics.” – Bob Boilen, on “Nightcat!”

AV Club
“The New Yorker undercuts the basic singer-songwriter fixings with pitch-warped harmonies and instruments ranging from melodica to harmonium to jaw harp. Each part of [the] arrangements quietly rises up to gently push the whole in a stranger direction.”